Printer ink is the purchase nobody enjoys, and the cartridge number matters more than the logo. After weeks with UK roundups, spec sheets and amazon.co.uk listings, the best ink cartridges for most HP owners start with the HP 305XL, a genuine high-yield black for the DeskJet and ENVY printers sitting in a lot of UK homes. Canon, Epson and Brother owners get a genuine pick each, then come the compatibles.
I didn't test these hands-on. Only the HP and Canon originals appear in editorial roundups; the rest are judged on their listings and specs. If you're after cheap ink cartridges for HP, Canon or Epson printers, the compatible packs further down are the budget route, but read the firmware warning first.

Which cartridge number each one is, which printers it fits, and where each one falls short.
#1 · Editor's Choice
Plenty of UK homes have an HP DeskJet or ENVY on a shelf, and this is the black cartridge many of them need. The HP 305XL (part 3YM63AE) is listed for DeskJet 2700, 2800 and Plus 4100 printers plus the ENVY 6000 and 6400. HP quotes about 240 pages, and with HP's own chip a firmware update shouldn't lock it out. My home-office printer mostly spits out return labels (that's most home printing, honestly), which suits a black XL. The limitation: it's black only, and genuine ink is pricier than the Lifor or ColoWorld compatibles.
The verdict: The safest black for HP 305 printers, if you'll pay for genuine ink.
#2 · Runner-Up
Let's get the one knock out of the way: this is black only, so your PIXMA will also need a CL-546XL for colour. Otherwise the Canon PG-545XL is the easy genuine choice, promising up to 400 A4 pages from 15 ml of ink across PIXMA TR, IP, MX, MG and TS printers. The printhead is built into the cartridge, so every swap brings fresh nozzles, handy for a printer that sits idle between school letters. The Ikonk two-pack is the remanufactured alternative.
The verdict: The genuine pick for PIXMA printers that take 545, with colour bought separately.
#3 · Best For Epson
Starfish is just Epson's name for its 603 range, so look for 603 on your old cartridges. This genuine 603XL multipack bundles high-yield black, cyan, magenta and yellow for Expression Home XP-2100 to XP-4100 and WorkForce WF-2810 to WF-2850 printers. Claria Home dye colours plus pigment black suit a family printer doing homework one day and holiday photos the next. The listing's yield figures contradict each other, so I've left them out. Colours rarely empty together either, so expect to buy singles or the GPC Image five-pack later.
The verdict: The easy genuine set for Epson 603 printers, though singles will follow.
#4 · Best For Brother
If you own a Brother DCP-J572DW, J772DW or J774DW, or an MFC-J491DW to J895DW, this is the genuine black your printer was built around. The LC-3211BK is standard yield, rated at about 200 pages with pigment black ink, and Brother says it protects your printer warranty. These compact all-in-ones tend to live on a box-room bookshelf printing invoices. But 200 pages doesn't go far, so heavier users should look at the LC3213 compatibles from LCL and Uniwork.
The verdict: Genuine, warranty-friendly black for small Brother inkjets and lighter printing.
#5 · Best Value
Here's a compatible that's clear about what it replaces. LCL lists these as LC3213, the high-capacity code for the printers the LC-3211BK serves, quoting about 400 pages per cartridge. Dye ink, a chip that shows ink levels and individual boxes, which I appreciate, since my desk drawer is where loose cartridges get crushed. The pack is muddled, though: one bullet mentions six colour cartridges, other details suggest four. Dye black may also look softer on plain paper than Brother's pigment.
The verdict: A sensible high-capacity Brother compatible, once you've checked the pack.
#6 · Best Budget
Budget first: this is the most practical way into compatible 603XL ink here. Two black cartridges plus a cyan, a magenta and a yellow match how most of us print, mainly black text with the odd colour chart. It's listed for Expression Home XP-2100 to XP-4155 and WorkForce WF-2810 onwards, with about 500 pages per black quoted. Colour yields differ between bullets and specs, and a future printer update can stop the chips being recognised. Go Inks' eight-pack is the bigger option.
The verdict: The most practical 603XL compatible, with a spare black most homes will use.
#7 · Best Uk Compatible
Two full sets in one box is the point: eight compatible 603XL cartridges, two of every colour. The listing quotes 18.2ml black and 14ml colour cartridges for WorkForce WF-2810 to WF-2870 and Expression Home XP-2100 onwards, from a UK-based supplier with a satisfaction guarantee. That's a lot to keep in a cupboard if you print a few pages a month, and ink can dry out. I'd only buy it for an Epson printing homework every week; otherwise the GPC Image five-pack is plenty.
The verdict: Only worth it for busy Epson printers; lighter users should buy the five-pack.
#8 · Best Multipack
Check the number first, because 364 is not 305. This ten-pack is a compatible HP 364XL set for older Photosmart printers such as the 5520 and 7520, plus the DeskJet 3070A and OfficeJet 4620. Four blacks come with two of every colour, the seller quotes up to 550 pages per black, and the chips report ink levels. Printers like these often linger in a spare bedroom long after the warranty ends, which is exactly what this pack suits. It does eat drawer space.
The verdict: A sensible stockpile for older HP 364 printers that are out of warranty.
#9 · Best For Hp Compatible
I'll be straight: I almost didn't include this one. Lifor sells a 305XL black and tri-colour pair for the same DeskJet and ENVY printers as the HP 305XL, with colour thrown in. But the details are thin. Product data I found calls it remanufactured with a reused HP chip, the title only says replacement, and yield figures vary across the listing. HP's Dynamic Security can reject non-HP chips after an update. The ColoWorld combo is the obvious rival.
The verdict: A pair for HP 305 printers, but the thin details make it a gamble.
#10 · Best Budget
Two blacks and nothing else. Ikonk's pack holds two remanufactured PG-545XL cartridges, a manual and an eraser, for PIXMA printers such as the TS3150, TS3450, TR4550 and MX495. The title promises 500-plus pages each while a bullet says about 450, so plan on the lower figure. Canon's 545 carries its own printhead, so these are refilled Canon shells, not new-built clones. For colour, add a CL-546XL or look at the Denvoer and Sunnieink combos.
The verdict: Two remanufactured blacks for Canon 545 printers; budget for colour separately.
We didn't test these ink cartridges hands-on or in a lab. The ranking is built from UK and international editorial roundups, manufacturer spec sheets and amazon.co.uk listings, checked against one another. Only the HP 305XL and Canon PG-545XL appear in those roundups; the other picks are judged on their published specs and listings. Where a listing contradicted itself, as with the LCL pack contents, I followed the title or left the figure out.
What we compared for every cartridge:
How we weighted the scores:
Original cartridges come from the printer maker. Compatibles are new cartridges built by a third party, like the GPC Image, Go Inks and LCL packs here. Remanufactured cartridges are used originals, cleaned and refilled, which is common for HP 305 and Canon 545 because their printheads sit inside the cartridge.
The chip is where things go wrong. Your printer reads a small chip on each cartridge, and a firmware update can change what it accepts. HP's Dynamic Security is the best-known example, and other makers can do the same, so a compatible that prints today can be rejected after an update. Brother says its genuine cartridges protect your printer warranty; if a third-party cartridge causes a fault, that repair may not be covered, so keep the box and receipt.
Start with the number. It's printed on the old cartridge and in the manual: HP 305 and 364, Canon PG-545 and CL-546, Epson 603, and Brother LC-3211 and LC3213 in this list. Two printers from the same brand can take different cartridges, so match the code, then check your model appears in the listing's compatibility list.
Next, standard or XL. High-yield cartridges hold more ink and are quoted at more pages. Originals follow ISO page-yield standards, and most compatibles quote figures at 5% coverage of an A4 sheet, far lighter than a page of dense text, so treat any yield as a guide. Multipacks cut down on orders, and packs with extra black suit mostly-text homes. Print only a few pages a month, though, and ink can dry before you finish an XL; my own printer goes weeks without a job, and the first page after a gap often comes out streaky.
Cheap ink cartridges for HP, Canon and Epson printers are almost always compatibles or remanufactured. They're the budget route and many work fine, but you accept the firmware risk; originals sit at the premium end. If you have an HP DeskJet or ENVY that takes 305 cartridges and just want it to print, buy the HP 305XL and call it a day. When it's empty, HP and Canon both run free recycling schemes.
| Product | Cartridge Type | Fits | Page Yield | Our Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HP 305XL High Yield Original Black Ink Cartridge | original HP high-yield black | HP DeskJet 2700/2700e/2800e, DeskJet Plus 4100, ENVY 6000/6400 series | approx 240 pages (ISO) | 9.9 |
| Canon PG-545XL Genuine Black Ink Cartridge | original Canon FINE high-yield black | Canon PIXMA TS3150/TS3350/TS3450, MG2550S, MG3050, TR4550 series | approx 400 pages | 9.8 |
| Epson 603XL Starfish Genuine 4-Colour Ink Multipack | original Epson Starfish XL multipack (BK/C/M/Y) | Epson Expression Home XP-2100/3100/4100, WorkForce WF-2810/2830/2850 | approx 500 pages black / 350 pages per colour | 9.6 |
| Brother LC-3211BK Genuine Black Ink Cartridge | original Brother standard-yield black | Brother DCP-J572DW, DCP-J772DW, DCP-J774DW, MFC-J491DW, MFC-J497DW, MFC-J890DW, MFC-J895DW | approx 200 pages | 9.4 |
| LCL LC3213 Compatible Ink Cartridges for Brother | compatible high-capacity (LC-3213) | Brother DCP-J572DW, DCP-J772DW, DCP-J774DW, MFC-J491DW, MFC-J497DW, MFC-J890DW, MFC-J895DW | approx 400 pages black / 400 pages colour | 9.2 |
| GPC Image 603XL Compatible Ink Cartridges, 5-Pack | compatible 603XL | Epson Expression Home XP-2100/2105/3100/3105/4100/4105, WorkForce WF-2810/2830/2835/2850 | approx 500 pages black / 450 pages colour | 9.0 |
| Go Inks 603XL Compatible Ink Cartridges, 8-Pack | compatible 603XL | Epson Expression Home XP-2100/2105/3100/3105/4100/4105, WorkForce WF-2810/2830/2835/2850 | approx 500 pages black / 450 pages colour | 8.8 |
| Smart Ink 364XL Compatible HP Ink Cartridges, 10-Pack | compatible 364XL | HP Photosmart 5510/5520/6520/7510/7520, DeskJet 3070A, OfficeJet 4620 | approx 550 pages black / 750 pages colour | 8.6 |
| Lifor 305XL Black and Tri-colour HP Replacement Cartridges | remanufactured 305XL | HP DeskJet 2700/2800e series, DeskJet Plus 4100/4200e, ENVY 6000/6400 series | approx 600 pages black / 450 pages colour | 8.4 |
| Ikonk PG-545XL Remanufactured Black Cartridges, 2-Pack | remanufactured PG-545XL black | Canon PIXMA TS3150/TS3350/TS3450, TR4550, MG2550S, MG3050, iP2850 | 500+ pages | 8.2 |
The best ink cartridges are the ones matching your printer's cartridge number, and genuine XL versions are the safest bet. That means the HP 305XL for HP 305 printers, the PG-545XL for Canon PIXMA models that take 545, and the Starfish 603XL multipack for Epson 603 owners. Compatibles suit tighter budgets.
Many are fine for everyday printing, but quality varies more than with genuine ink. Compatibles are new third-party cartridges with their own chips; remanufactured ones are refilled originals. The real risk is a firmware update that stops a chip being recognised, so buy from sellers that state the exact cartridge number.
Usually, yes, if you print every week. XL cartridges hold more ink, so you swap them less often; the HP 305XL is rated at about 240 pages and the Canon PG-545XL at up to 400. If you print a few pages a month, a standard cartridge can make more sense, because ink dries out.
Yes, it can. Printer makers push firmware updates that check cartridge chips, and HP's Dynamic Security is the best-known example. A compatible that worked yesterday can be rejected after an update, so read the seller's guidance on updates and check the returns policy before opening the pack.
Read the number printed on your old cartridge, or check the printer manual. Codes like HP 305, Canon PG-545, Epson 603 and Brother LC-3211 matter more than the printer's name. Match that code to the listing, then check your printer model appears in its compatibility list.
Refilling can cost less, but it's messy and results vary. Home refill kits mean injecting ink into a used cartridge, which suits tinkerers. Remanufactured cartridges, like the Ikonk PG-545XL pack, are the professional version of that idea. For most households, a well-described compatible or a genuine XL is less fiddly.
If you own an HP DeskJet or ENVY that takes 305 cartridges, the HP 305XL is the one I'd buy. Canon PIXMA owners should start with the PG-545XL, Epson 603 owners with the Starfish 603XL multipack, and Brother households with the LC-3211BK. Whichever you pick, match the number on your old cartridge first.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our affiliate disclosure for details. Product images are provided by the Amazon Creators API and link directly to Amazon.