Laser printers are low-fuss until you order the wrong toner. After weeks with UK roundups, spec sheets and amazon.co.uk listings, the best toner cartridge for most home offices is the Brother TN-2420, a genuine high-yield black for the Brother mono lasers parked under a lot of UK desks. HP, Kyocera and Pantum owners get a genuine pick each, then come the compatible toner cartridges.
I didn't test these hands-on. Only the Brother and HP originals appear in editorial roundups; the rest are judged on their listings and specs. Whatever you buy, match the code on your old cartridge first.

Which toner code each one is, which laser printers it fits, and where each one falls short.
#1 · Editor's Choice
This is the toner I'd buy for the Brother mono laser that seems to live in every other UK home office. The TN-2420 is the genuine high-yield black for HL-L2310D to HL-L2375DW, DCP-L2510D to L2550DN and the MFC-L2710DW and L2750DW, rated at up to 3,000 pages under ISO/IEC 19752, and Brother says genuine toner protects your printer warranty. My own laser sits under the desk printing invoices and the odd tax form, exactly the steady mono work this suits. The limitation is Brother's split design, though: the DR-2400 drum isn't included, and you'll buy one eventually.
The verdict: The genuine high-yield toner for Brother's popular mono lasers; just budget for the drum.
#2 · Runner-Up
Small LaserJets like the M110w and M140w fit on a hallway shelf in a flat, and the 142A is what keeps them going. It's HP's original W1420A toner for the M110w and M110we, MFP M139w and MFP M140w and M140we, with an HP chip and about 950 pages per cartridge. That yield is the snag: a busy home office will get through it quickly, where the Brother TN-2420 lasts far longer. The Skydo and Baisine compatibles' listings say they won't work with 'e' models or HP+, so I'd stick with the original.
The verdict: The safe original for small HP LaserJets, especially e-series models.
#3 · Best Long Life
If you've got a Kyocera ECOSYS P5026 or M5526 colour laser, this is its black toner, and the yield is the reason to care. Kyocera rates the TK-5240K at about 4,000 pages under ISO/IEC 19798, the longest rating here. It's toner only, because Kyocera keeps a long-life drum inside the printer, so swaps take seconds. You'll still buy cyan, magenta and yellow separately, and these printers are more small office than spare room. I'd still pick it over a compatible for a printer that's still under warranty.
The verdict: A long-lasting genuine black for Kyocera ECOSYS colour lasers.
#4 · Best Budget
Pantum is the budget laser brand plenty of people buy without realising the toner is its own design. The PA-210 is the original cartridge for the P2500W, P2502W, M6500W, M6500NW and M6600NW families, rated at up to 1,600 pages at 5% coverage. Toner and drum come as one unit, so every swap gives you a fresh drum, which keeps things simple. The obvious limit is that it only fits Pantum's own printers, and I couldn't find editorial coverage of it. Owners have few genuine alternatives anyway.
The verdict: The only sensible genuine option for Pantum printers, with a drum built in.
#5 · Best Value
Compatible toner makes most sense for a printer already out of warranty, and HP's LaserJet Pro M404 is a common one in small offices. LCL's 59A replacement (CF259A) is listed for the M304a, the M404 range and MFP M428 models, with a quoted 3,000 pages and a pre-fitted chip that reports toner levels. It ships in its own box, which suits a stationery cupboard. HP's Dynamic Security can still reject compatible chips after a firmware update, so keep the receipt. The Everyday by Xerox version is the branded alternative.
The verdict: A sensible compatible 59A for out-of-warranty HP LaserJet Pro printers.
#6 · Best Twin Pack
Two cartridges in one box suits a Brother laser that prints all week. GPC Image's pack holds two compatible TN2420 blacks, also replacing TN2410, for the same HL-L2350DW to MFC-L2750DW printers as the genuine toner, with roughly 3,000 pages claimed for each. The listing clearly says non-original. Remember the drum: Brother uses a separate one, and no compatible toner changes that. No editorial coverage turned up, so this is a listing-based pick, but next to the LxTek single it's the better option for heavy printing.
The verdict: Good for busy Brother lasers, as long as you accept a listing-only pick.
#7 · Best For Hp Colour
Colour lasers need four toners, and this is just the black one. HenceBuy's compatible 207A (W2210A) fits Color LaserJet Pro M255dw, M255nw, MFP M282nw, M283fdn and M283fdw printers, and the seller rates it at about 1,350 pages. Black usually runs out first in a home office, so a single black makes sense, and it avoids buying a full set like the Smart Ink four-pack. HP firmware can block compatible chips after updates, and there's no editorial backing here.
The verdict: A single compatible black for HP Color LaserJet Pro owners who print mostly text.
#8 · Best Branded Compatible
Most compatibles come from brands you've never heard of; this one is Xerox's own Everyday range. It's a compatible HP 59A (CF259A, Xerox part 006R04418) for LaserJet Pro M304 and M404 printers and Enterprise M406 and M430 models, standard capacity, at about 3,000 pages. Xerox promises a replacement cartridge if there's an issue, and the packaging is plastic-free. It's still a compatible, so an update from HP can stop it working. Against the LCL 59A, you're mostly paying for a name you recognise.
The verdict: A compatible from a name you know, with a replacement promise behind it.
#9 · Best Colour Multipack
A full colour set in one order is the appeal. Smart Ink's compatible 207A pack has black, cyan, magenta and yellow for Color LaserJet Pro M255 and MFP M282 and M283 printers, with up to 1,350 pages for black and 1,250 per colour quoted, plus chips that track toner levels. Colours rarely run out together, though, so you may end up with spares in a drawer. HP's firmware risk applies here as well, and no reviewer coverage turned up.
The verdict: A one-order colour refill for HP 207A printers, with the usual chip caveat.
#10 · Cheapest Brother
Simple listing, simple job. LxTek's compatible TN2420 is a single black toner for Brother HL-L2350DW, HL-L2375DW, DCP-L2530DW and MFC-L2710DW printers, claiming 3,000 pages per cartridge. The box holds one cartridge and nothing else, and the listing says plainly it's not original. Beyond fit and yield, details are thin. If you print a lot, the GPC Image two-pack makes more sense.
The verdict: A basic single TN2420 compatible; heavier users should buy the two-pack.
We didn't test these toner cartridges hands-on or in a lab. The ranking is built from UK and international editorial roundups, manufacturer spec sheets and amazon.co.uk listings, checked against one another. Only the Brother TN-2420 and HP 142A appear in those roundups; the other picks are judged on their published specs and listings. Where details disagreed, I followed the title.
What we compared for every cartridge:
How we weighted the scores:
Toner is the powder that forms the print, and the drum transfers it to the paper. Printers handle the drum differently. Brother splits them, so the TN-2420 toner and the DR-2400 drum are bought separately. Pantum's PA-210 puts both in one cartridge, and Kyocera keeps a long-life drum inside the printer, so its TK-5240K is toner only. Check which design your printer uses before ordering.
Original toner comes from the printer maker; compatible toner is made by a third party, like the LCL, GPC Image and Everyday by Xerox picks here. Both carry a chip that the printer reads, and a firmware update can change what it accepts. HP's Dynamic Security is the best-known example. Several HP compatibles in this list, including the Skydo, Baisine and Inkjello, say plainly that they don't work with printer models ending in 'e' or with the HP+ service.
Start with the code on your old cartridge: TN-2420, HP 142A, 59A, 207A or 135A, TK-5240K or PA-210 in this list. Match it, then check your printer appears in the listing's compatibility list.
Next, page yield. Original mono toners are rated under ISO/IEC 19752 and colour toners under ISO/IEC 19798, while most compatibles quote figures at 5% coverage of an A4 page. Dense pages use more, so treat yields as a guide. High yield toner such as the TN-2420 holds more powder, so you change it less often, and unlike ink, toner doesn't dry out between jobs. That makes a laser the better home printer if, like me, you print in bursts and then forget about it for a month.
Mono or colour matters too. A colour laser like the HP Color LaserJet Pro M255 needs four toners, and black usually goes first, which is why a single black like the HenceBuy can make more sense than a full set.
Compatible toner is the budget route, but you accept the chip risk; originals sit at the premium end. If you own a Brother HL-L2350DW or one of its siblings and just want it to print, buy the genuine TN-2420 and call it a day. When a cartridge is empty, HP takes its own back free through HP Planet Partners.
| Product | Toner Type | Fits | Page Yield | Our Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brother TN-2420 High Yield Genuine Black Toner Cartridge | original Brother high-yield mono toner | Brother HL-L2310D, HL-L2350DW, HL-L2370DN, HL-L2375DW, DCP-L2510D, DCP-L2530DW, DCP-L2550DN, MFC-L2710DW, MFC-L2750DW | approx 3,000 pages (ISO/IEC 19752) | 9.9 |
| HP 142A Original LaserJet Black Toner Cartridge, W1420A | original HP mono toner (W1420A) | HP LaserJet M110w/M110we, MFP M139w, MFP M140w/M140we | approx 950 pages | 9.8 |
| Kyocera TK-5240K Original Black Toner Cartridge, 1T02R70NL0 | original Kyocera black toner (TK-5240K) | Kyocera ECOSYS P5026cdn, P5026cdw, M5526cdn, M5526cdw | approx 4,000 pages | 9.6 |
| Pantum PA-210 Original Toner Cartridge with Built-in Drum | original Pantum mono toner | Pantum P2500W, P2502W, M6500W, M6500NW, M6550NW, M6600NW | approx 1,600 pages | 9.4 |
| LCL 59A CF259A Compatible Toner Cartridge for HP, with Chip | compatible HP 59A (CF259A) with chip | HP LaserJet Pro M304a, M404n, M404dn, M404dw, MFP M428dw, M428fdn, M428fdw | approx 3,000 pages | 9.2 |
| GPC Image TN2420 Compatible Toner Cartridges for Brother, 2-Pack | compatible TN-2420 high yield | Brother HL-L2350DW, HL-L2370DN, HL-L2375DW, DCP-L2530DW, DCP-L2550DN, MFC-L2710DW, MFC-L2750DW | approx 3,000 pages each | 9.0 |
| HenceBuy 207A Compatible Black Toner Cartridge for HP, with Chip | compatible HP 207A black with chip | HP Color LaserJet Pro M255dw, M255nw, MFP M282nw, M283fdn, M283fdw | approx 1,350 pages | 8.8 |
| Everyday by Xerox Compatible HP 59A CF259A Toner Cartridge | Xerox Everyday compatible for HP 59A (CF259A) | HP LaserJet Pro M304a, M404n, M404dn, M404dw, MFP M428dw, M428fdn, M428fdw | approx 3,000 pages | 8.6 |
| Smart Ink 207A Compatible Toner Cartridges for HP, 4-Colour Pack | compatible HP 207A set | HP Color LaserJet Pro M255dw, M255nw, MFP M282nw, M283fdn, M283fdw | approx 1,350 pages black / 1,250 pages colour | 8.4 |
| LxTek TN2420 Compatible Toner Cartridge for Brother | compatible TN-2420 | Brother HL-L2350DW, HL-L2375DW, DCP-L2530DW, MFC-L2710DW, MFC-L2750DW | approx 3,000 pages | 8.2 |
The best toner cartridge is the genuine one made for your printer's code, if you can stretch to it. That's the TN-2420 for Brother HL-L2350DW-type printers, the 142A for small HP LaserJets and the TK-5240K for Kyocera ECOSYS colour models. Compatible toner from LCL, GPC Image or Everyday by Xerox is the budget route.
Your printer's own brand is usually best, because its chip and toner are designed together. Brother, HP, Kyocera and Pantum all make originals here. Among compatibles, Everyday by Xerox is the one name most people will recognise, while LCL, GPC Image and LxTek are listing-based picks without editorial backing.
Many work well for everyday documents, but quality varies more than with originals. The bigger worry is the chip, since a printer firmware update can stop a compatible being recognised. Buy one that names your exact toner code, and keep the receipt.
Toner is the powder that forms the print; the drum transfers it onto paper. Brother printers that take the TN-2420 use a separate drum, the DR-2400, which is replaced less often. Pantum's PA-210 combines both in one cartridge, and Kyocera keeps a long-life drum inside the printer.
Usually, yes, if you print regularly. High-yield cartridges such as the TN-2420 hold more toner, so you change them less often. Toner doesn't dry out the way ink does, so a big cartridge won't go to waste if you print in bursts. Store spares sealed.
Probably not. Several compatible listings here, including the Skydo, Baisine and Inkjello, say they don't work with printer models ending in 'e' or with the HP+ service. If your LaserJet is one of those, genuine HP toner like the 142A is the safe choice.
For a Brother mono laser that takes TN-2420, the genuine high-yield toner is the one I'd buy. Small HP LaserJet owners should stick with the original 142A, especially on e-series models, and Kyocera ECOSYS colour users with the TK-5240K. If your printer is out of warranty and you want compatible toner, the LCL 59A and the GPC Image two-pack are sensible starting points.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our affiliate disclosure for details. Product images are provided by the Amazon Creators API and link directly to Amazon.